In mainstream orthodox judaism and in conservative and reform judaism, this practice simply isnt a thing. Hes the greatest mohel who ever lived in history, he said. Metzitza drawing blood during circumcision is an essential part of brit mila circumcision. Are new york hospitals hiding herpes from metzitzah bpeh. Another newborn herpes case tied to metzitzah in ny jewish week. Metzitzah bpeh circumcision ritual inconsistent with. Greenfield introduced a bill that would bar the new york city department of health and mental hygiene from requi. The goal is to put metzitzah b peh out of reach of any change. Generalized anxiety disorder understanding the nature of worry and anxiety duration. New york city officials linked the practice to 17 cases of.
It relates the story that a mohel who was suspected of transmitting herpes via metzizah. The cdc estimates that 3,600 newborn boys a year in new york have circumcisions that include the procedure, which puts them at more than triple the normal risk of contracting hsv1. He therefore asked sofer to give him permission to do brit milah without metzitzah bpeh. The brit milah is a jewish religious male circumcision ceremony performed by a mohel. Oct 17, 2015 in the consent, the parent acknowledges that he or she is aware that the department recommends dos, also known as metzitzah b peh, not be performed because of the risk of brain damage and death. Metzitzah bpeh direct oral suctioning new york city. The controversial and potentially lifethreatening practice of metzitzah bpeh, the oral suctioning of a babys circumcision wound by the mohel, is back in the news. The new york city department of health ordered the mohel to stop performing metzitzah b peh. Regulation of circumcision method divides some jews the new. A young father to twin boys contemplates the concept of a bris in general and its controversial aspects such as metzitzah bpeh. The ancient method of performing metzitzahmetzitzah bpeh, or oral suction 35 36 has become controversial. The metzitzah bpeh controversy by special to crosscurrents may 18, 2006 several readers, who are not jewish observer subscribers, wanted to read the article on metzitzah bpeh by r chaim dovid zweibel to which jonathan rosenblum referred earlier today. Due to the stigma of syphilis, an 1883 textbook of the venereal disease. The history of metzitzah bpeh, the controversial direct mouthtobleedingpenis suction done by many haredi mohels immediately after cutting.
According to the new york times, metzitzah b peh remains commonplace among the more than 250,000 ultraorthodox jews in the new york area. Have a safe bris for your baby brochure pdf other languages pdf. Ritual circumcision, metzitzah bpeh, syphilis, syphilophobia, mohel, lower east. Michael savage mocks practice of metzitzah bpeh and. Aug 15, 2012 jerusalem the israeli pediatric association has come out publicly against the controversial practice of orogentital suction, known in hebrew as metzitzah bpeh, in which a ritual circumciser applies direct oral suction to a babys still open circumcision wound. Metzitzah bpeh blood sucking jewish ritual, has caused.
Some forums can only be seen by registered members. Metzitzah bpeh is when the mohel uses his mouth to suck blood away from the babys circumcision wound as part of the circumcision ritual. Two infants diagnosed with herpes after metzitzah bpeh. Wertheim asked viennas chief rabbi elazar horowitz for permission to substitute manually applied pressure with cotton gauze for mbp. Do regulations of oral suction of blood after circumcision. Herpes cases among babies linked to ultraorthodox jewish. Daniel korobkin some time ago, a series of babies became infected with serious, lifethreatening sores in their groin areas shortly after they were circumcised. Like circumcision itself, metzitzah bpeh goes back to biblical times.
Bris revisionist history exploring forbidden facts. In almost all of the circumcisions cohn performed, he practiced the ancient controversial practice of metzitzah b peh in which the mohel places his mouth directly on the circumcision wound to draw blood away from the cut. Ritual circumcision, metzitzah bpeh, syphilis, syphilophobia, mohel. Throughout history, rabbis and thinkers have offered additional arguments in favor of. Rabbi performs controversial metzitzah bpeh circumcision.
Five years ago, there was a public controversy related to metzitzah b peh. The majority of jewish circumcision ceremonies do not include metzitzah bpeh, in which the mohel, or circumciser, places their mouth directly on. Jan 28, 2006 doctors have long been concerned that the act, called metzitzah bpeh in hebrew, could spread disease, but their argument became urgent last year when new york city health officials said. Dec 05, 2012 please register to participate in our discussions with 2 million other members its free and quick. By exploring the historical context of this littleknown outbreak and investigation. Several years ago the city concluded that the metzitzah bpeh procedure created unacceptable risks for newborns in terms of the transmission of neonatal herpes through contact with a mohel. The tradition of metzitzah bpeh goes back to biblical times but has created a modernday dilemma for religiously observant jews. Horowitz got approval for the substitution from the chatam sofer. The majority of jewish circumcision ceremonies do not use metzitzah b peh, but some. Radio talk show host michael savage dedicated his entire show on april 8 to the story of infants allegedly contracting herpes following a bris with metzitzah bpeh.
Heres a brief history of the rise and fall of metzitzah bpeh the. Democratic mayoral candidates discuss metzitzah bpeh. Metzitzah bpeh, rabbinic polemics and applying the lessons. Infants contract herpes from oral suction during jewish. Religious protections are worth keeping national catholic. Metzitzah bpeh, which literally means oral suction, is first mentioned in the. At a mayoral forum hosted by the jewish press 0529. Metzitzah b peh was originally mentioned in halachic texts the mishna, approximately 200 ce as an entirely practical part of the procedure, along with placing cumin thought to have healing. Metzitzah bpeh was originally mentioned in halachic texts the mishna, approximately 200 ce as an entirely practical part of the procedure, along with placing cumin thought to have healing properties at the time and a bandage on the wound mishna shabbos 19. Metzitzah bpeh circumcision ritual causing herpes in infants. A brit milah, also known as a bris, is the jewish ceremony in which a baby boy is circumcised. Metzitzah controversy arrives in israel by sam sokol the 5. When i trained as a mohel, my understanding then and now is that the talmud explains metzitzah as a method to prevent illness by drawing blood away from the wound to remove impurities. Apr 03, 2017 time for orthodox jews to oppose metzitzah bpeh oral suction was originally if, now, mistakenly intended as a hygienic, not halachic, act.
Pedophilic jewish religious rituals metzitzah bpeh. Another element of concern is the elevation of metzitzah b peh from an ancillary step not even considered part of the mitzvah, to a halakha lmoshe misinai, a law transmitted by moses on mount sinai. Wertheim attributed the deaths to metzitzah bpeh mbp, because all the dead had incurable rashes on their genitals. The hebrew term metzitzah bpeh, often shortened to mbp, refers to a procedure practiced by some ultraorthodox mohels as part of a male infants circumcision rite in which the mohel orally.
Two more babies contracted herpes this year as a consequence of metzitzah bpeh mbp, part of the jewish ultra orthodox way of performing circumcisions or bris milah, in which the mohel circumciser performs oral suction on the freshly circumcised penis of the baby. Nov 28, 20 the metzitzah has been part of the milah process, and so getting rid of it, even if we think that the original reason is batel, is more of an issue, which is why many poskim will go against metzitzah b peh, but getting rid of metzitzah altogether is something you dont see in practice, even if it makes some sense in theory. A newborns death after a jewish ritual reflects the gap between faith and the mind. Metzitzah bpeh, which literally means oral suction, is first mentioned in the babylonian talmud in tractate shabbos, which dates back to the 4th century. The vast majority of jewish circumcision ceremonies do not use metzitzah bpeh, 37 but some hasidic.
According to the new york times, metzitzah bpeh remains commonplace among the more than 250,000 ultraorthodox jews in the new york area. He therefore asked the chasam sofer to give him permission to do brit milah without metzitzah bpeh and when he presented the defense in court they erroneously recorded his testimony to mean that the chasam sofer stated it as a general ruling. Circumcision dates back to the book of genesis, when god commands. He also tells the the history of mbp, and quotes some of the discussions about it from the 19th century. Inspire a love of reading with prime book box for kids discover delightful childrens books with prime book box, a subscription that delivers new books every 1. Sep 05, 2012 there is no doubt that insistence on metzitzah bpeh is wrong. Brit milah project gutenberg selfpublishing ebooks. My intention is, irrespective of whether it should be done or not, where does the notion come from in the first place. As a result, some doctors condemned the practice of metzitzah bpeh, and sought.
He then discusses the psak of the chasam sofer who didnt even consider metzitzah bpeh to be a minhag. In metzitzah b peh, the mohel rabbinic circumciser performs fellatio on the infant boy by placing the infants penis in his mouth and sucking the blood from the circumcised member. The bible does not authorize any use of metzitzah b peh. Metzitzah bpeh, vouchers, weiner charms the crowd jacob kornbluh there are not many issues the democratic mayoral hopefuls agree on, especially when they are seated at one table. The cdc estimates that 3,600 newborn boys a year in new york have. Oct 01, 20 haaretz reported today that a couple of weeks ago, new york city councilman david g. After metzitzah b peh, some babies can get an infection. The next part shows that metzitzah bpeh is a danger and many cases are cited where it has unfortunately caused harm to infants. Tradition tradition journal of the pediatric infectious. It is spoken of very positively in the jewish literature on circumcision both as an essential part of the ritual and as a health measure which. Jun 12, 20 jonathan friedman discusses circumcision and metzitzah b peh and how they have impacted his life. How ancient circumcision rite sparked modern schism the. After you create your account, youll be able to customize options and access all our 15,000 new postsday with fewer ads. Why no metzitzah bpeh no oral suction circumcision ask.
Ritual circumcision in the age of germ theory amongst nineteenth. He tells the story that a student of moses sofer, lazar horowitz, chief rabbi of vienna at the time and author of the responsa yad elazer, needed the ruling because of a governmental attempt to ban circumcision completely if it included metztitzah bpeh. Metzitzah bpeh direct oral suctioning when a baby is circumcised, some ritual jewish circumcisers mohelim do a practice called metzitzah bpeh. Infectious disease experts widely agree that the oral contact, known in hebrew as metzitzah bpeh, creates a risk of transmission of herpes that. Yes, this practice is called metzitzah bpeh, and it happens only in some. The process has the mohel place his mouth directly on the circumcision wound to draw blood away from the cut. Heres a brief history of the controversy surrounding metzitzah bpeh.
The traditional practice of metzitzah bpeh, which has its roots in the earliest history of the jewish people and has survived unchanged to the present time, should be viewed with great respect. The practice has come under increasing fire in the united states on the heels of a report. An orthodox mohel had allegedly transmitted the herpes simplex virus to a number of infants resulting in illness and death. The late late show with james corden recommended for. In almost all of the circumcisions cohn performed, he practiced the ancient controversial practice of metzitzah bpeh in which the mohel places his mouth directly on the circumcision wound to draw blood away from the cut.
Some hasidic jews practice metzitzah bpeh, in which the mohel the specially trained person performing the circumcision uses oral suction to draw blood from the area of the. Asked after the ceremony whether he performed the controversial rite metzitzah bpeh, also known as mbp, in which a ritual circumciser places his mouth on the babys genitals to suction blood. Thus, the same way one cannot write in a library book, one cannot get a. Metzitzah b peh is when the mohel uses his mouth to suck blood away from the babys circumcision wound as part of the circumcision ritual. New york fails to enforce consent forms for metzitzah bpeh circumcision rite. I firmly believe that making metzitzah bpehis a criminal act.
The majority of jewish circumcision ceremonies do not use metzitzah bpeh, but some haredi jews use it. David bleich, a professor of both jewish and secular law at yeshiva university, said the debate over metzitzah b peh began in europe during the mid19th century, when suspicion arose that. In fact, if you had a surgical circumcision as a baby from a doctor or surgeon and th. The next time you hear someone trying to minimize male genital mutilation direct them to this graphic video of the ancient jewish circumcision ritual of metzitzah bpeh, where, after circumcising the infant boy the rabbi sucks the bleeding penis. Neonatal herpes following ritual circumcision metzitzah b. Metzitzah bpeh oral suction the ancient method of performing metzitzah bpeh hebrew.
Time for orthodox jews to oppose metzitzah bpeh jewish week. Heres a brief history of the rise and fall of metzitzah b. Jul 29, 2014 infants contract herpes from oral suction during jewish circumcision the young turks. Inspire a love of reading with prime book box for kids discover delightful childrens books with prime book box, a subscription that delivers new books every 1, 2, or 3 months new customers receive 15% off your first box. Circumcision dates back to the book of genesis, when god commands abraham to circumcise himself and his offspring as a sign of the covenant between jews and god. In late february 2020, new york city health officials reported 3 additional neonatal herpes cases in infants who went through ritual jewish circumcision. The city estimates that metzitzah bpeh is used in some 3,600 local circumcisions each year. Rabbinic polemics and applying the lessons of history n. Mar 08, 2017 another newborn herpes case tied to metzitzah in ny. For printable resources about this practice and its risks, download. American officials ignored reality since throughout history, syphilis has. Thus in orthodox judaism, but not in the bible, one of the first experiences a judaic male baby undergoes. Metzitzah bpeh circumcision ritual inconsistent with jewish principles 06142012 06.
Lets suffice it to say that there were some halachic authorities that insisted that the metzitzah part of the circumcision must be done bpeh with the mouth, while others found workarounds albeit only in terms of danger to the child, not that this was the accepted norm of how it should be done. Circumcisions that include dos involve direct contact between the mouth of the practitioner designated by the religious community to perform a. Only a few, ultraultra orthodox sectscommunities do it. Metzitzah bpeh, which literally means oral suction, is first mentioned in the babylonian talmud in tractate shabbos, which dates back to the 4th. Jul 25, 2014 two infants diagnosed with herpes after metzitzah bpeh since 2012 the ny health department requires parents to sign a consent form prior to controversial jewish circumcision practice.
The majority of jewish circumcision ceremonies do not use metzitzah bpeh, but some. Human rights activist jonathan friedman spoke with a woman on the street about the bloodsucking ritual, metzitzah bpeh that follows ritual male. Back to the source to better understand the issues, we first need to examine the reason why. The ancient method of performing metzitzahmetzitzah bpeh, or oral suction has become controversial. But 19th century doctors and rabbis thought they reformed the rite for.
1479 226 900 538 27 9 1225 682 518 171 1078 528 942 1292 758 1235 1332 163 367 849 988 270 497 869 475 924 1122 759 74 380 502 692 534 465 389 1462 725 868 795 1351 764